Work out what your cargo declarations cost and whether commission covers it

In short: You can estimate the staff cost of manual cargo declarations with three numbers: how many minutes one declaration takes your team (Step 1), what a staff minute costs (Step 2), and how many declarations you handle each month (Step 3). Then compare the result with the commission each declaration earns (Step 4).
The queue nobody measures
Shipment details arrive by email, in spreadsheets and as PDFs, and each one waits for someone to open it, chase what is missing, key it in, check it, issue the certificate, raise the invoice and add it to the month's bordereau. Cargo teams live with this queue every day, yet few track what it costs. We found no published figure for it.
That queue is where most of the work in a cargo book sits. In the November announcement of tigerlab Brokerage, Holm Schimanski, partner and chief AI officer at tigerlab, put it simply: "Managing the policy is only part of the job." The heavier load, he said, comes from the volume of declarations, the transactions behind each one and the reporting that follows.
Where that load comes from is covered in an earlier piece. This one puts a number on it.
Who this calculation is for
The calculation applies to declaration-based open covers. On a standard obligatory open cover, the client must declare every shipment within scope, and each of those declarations has to be entered, certified, invoiced and reported. A standard legal text on cargo insurance notes that the London market often drops individual declarations and rates the cover on annual turnover instead. If most of your book works that way, the work described below is much smaller.
Step 1: Work out how much time one declaration takes
Before you can cost a declaration, you need to know how much staff time it uses. That covers everything from receiving the shipment details to issuing the certificate, invoicing and updating the bordereau.
Record the time your team spends on each activity, including chasing missing information and correcting mistakes. Add the minutes together to get the total staff time for one declaration.
Activity | Work involved | Staff time |
|---|---|---|
Receive | Open and review the shipment details | ___ min |
Chase | Follow up on missing information | ___ min |
Enter | Key the shipment into the system | ___ min |
Check | Verify value, voyage, rate and premium | ___ min |
Certify and invoice | Issue the certificate and the invoice | ___ min |
Report | Update the bordereau and reconcile | ___ min |
Total | Staff time per declaration | ___ min |
Count the combined time of everyone involved. If one person spends 5 minutes entering a declaration and another spends 4 minutes checking it, the staff time is 9 minutes.
Time a typical week, including the busy days, so that rework is part of the average.
As you record the time, note any task where the same shipment details are entered more than once, such as copying them from a spreadsheet into your system or into the bordereau, and how long it takes. We'll come back to these at the end.
Step 2: Calculate the cost of one staff minute
Now that you know how many minutes a declaration takes, you need to know what each of those minutes costs your business.
Start with an annual salary, add the employer's statutory costs, then divide by the minutes actually available for work in a year. Practical working time allows for breaks, training and other time that is paid but not spent on tasks.
Calculation | Example |
|---|---|
Annual salary | £29,000 |
Employer National Insurance | £3,600 |
Total annual employment cost | £32,600 |
Practical working hours per year | 1,560 |
Practical working minutes per year | 93,600 |
Cost per staff minute (£32,600 ÷ 93,600) | £0.35 |
Where these come from: the salary is the official median for insurance and pensions administrators (ONS, ASHE 2025, SOC 4132), the latest official figure published for this job. National Insurance uses the official HMRC rate of 15% on salary above £5,000 (2026/27). The 1,560 practical hours assume a 37.5-hour week, 52 weeks a year, with 80% of paid time counted as practical, as Kaplan and Anderson suggest. Replace any of these with your own figures.
This approach follows a published costing method, time-driven activity-based costing, set out by Robert Kaplan of Harvard Business School and Steven Anderson. It only needs two inputs: the cost of a minute and the minutes a task takes.
Step 3: Calculate your cost per declaration
You now have the two figures you need:
- staff minutes per declaration (Step 1)
- cost per staff minute (Step 2)
Multiply them to get the staff cost of one declaration. Then multiply by the number of declarations your team handles each month to see the wider cost.
Calculation | How it is worked out | Result |
|---|---|---|
Staff time per declaration | From Step 1 (example) | 15 min |
Cost per staff minute | From Step 2 | £0.35 |
Cost per declaration | 15 × £0.35 | £5.25 |
Declarations per month | Example | 400 |
Monthly staff cost | 400 × £5.25 | £2,100 |
Annual staff cost | £2,100 × 12 | £25,200 |
The 15 minutes and 400 declarations are round example figures, not data from any real broker. Use your own Step 1 total and your own volume.
This is a basic staff cost estimate. It counts salary and employer National Insurance only, not pensions, office costs, systems or management time.
Step 4: Compare the cost with the commission earned
Knowing what it costs to process a declaration is half the picture. The other half is whether the commission it earns covers that cost.
Commission comes from three things: the insured value of the shipment, the premium rate, and the agreed commission percentage. Published broker disclosures put cargo commission at 10% to 20% (a large broker in Canada) and 7.5% from one insurer (a broker in Ireland). This example uses a premium rate of 0.12% and a commission of 15%, both chosen for illustration.
Calculation | Large shipment | Small shipment |
|---|---|---|
Insured value | £350,000 | £20,000 |
Premium rate | 0.12% | 0.12% |
Premium | £420.00 | £24.00 |
Commission rate | 15% | 15% |
Commission earned | £63.00 | £3.60 |
Staff handling cost (Step 3) | £5.25 | £5.25 |
Difference | +£57.75 | −£1.65 |
Both declarations take the same 15 minutes, but the large shipment earns 17.5 times as much commission. The small one earns £3.60 against £5.25 of handling cost, a £1.65 shortfall before any other expense. Volume alone does not show whether a cargo book is worth the work.
Across the whole month
Some covers carry a minimum or deposit premium, so a single declaration does not always bring in new money on the day it is keyed. The fairer test is the monthly average. Continuing the same example of 400 declarations:
Calculation | How it is worked out | Result |
|---|---|---|
Average insured value per declaration | Example | £72,500 |
Average premium | £72,500 × 0.12% | £87.00 |
Average commission per declaration | £87.00 × 15% | £13.05 |
Staff cost per declaration | From Step 3 | £5.25 |
Left after handling cost, per declaration | £13.05 − £5.25 | £7.80 |
Left after handling cost, per month | 400 × £7.80 | £3,120 |
In this example the cover makes a contribution of £7.80 per declaration after the estimated handling cost. That is not profit: pensions, rent, systems and management time still have to come out of it. The small shipments are where the contribution disappears.
What the calculation shows, and its limits
What it shows
- How much staff time your declarations use, and what that time costs each month.
- Which shipments, and which clients, cost more to handle than they earn. Judge the whole client: one with many small shipments and a few large ones may still be profitable overall.
Its limits
- Your profit. It counts salary and employer National Insurance only. Pensions, rent, systems and management time still have to come out of what is left.
- Whether a loss is costing you cash yet. Your staff are paid anyway. The loss becomes real money when volume forces a new hire, overtime or a missed month-end.
- An exact figure. The minutes are estimates. A few days of honest timing gives a better number than a confident guess.
What to do with your number
Once you know what each declaration costs to process, you can start looking at where that cost can be reduced.
Some improvements come down to how information is collected. Ask clients to send shipment details in one structured list each month instead of separate emails, and give every client the same declaration template, so fewer details go missing.
Others come down to how the work moves through your team. Go back to the tasks you noted in Step 1 where the same shipment details were entered more than once. tigerlab Brokerage brings shipment declarations, certificates, invoicing and bordereau reporting into one platform, so each shipment is keyed once. Following up on missing information and handling exceptions may still need your team.
At renewal, review whether the cover structure still suits the client's declaration volume. Where the administrative work justifies it, consider an additional service fee, agreed with the client. The same number can guide hiring, because it shows whether the next administrator is needed or whether the process needs fixing first.
See tigerlab Brokerage in four minutes: the tour covers open covers and declarations at 2:50. Watch the 4-minute tour